Two Are True

The director's cut · web only

The Psychology of "Ambiguous Loss" & the Theology of Honest Lament

A web-only companion to Chapter 9 — why grieving someone who is still living is so heavy, the true story of Horatio Spafford’s 1873 shipwreck, and why God commended Job over his polite friends.

When someone you love goes through a major surgery, brain injury, dementia, or life-altering change, you can find yourself sitting right next to them in the living room while missing them at the exact same time. Family therapist and researcher Dr. Pauline Boss coined the term "ambiguous loss" (Ambiguous Loss: Learning to Live with Unresolved Grief, 1999) to describe this exact ache: when a loved one is physically present but psychologically or relationally changed. Because there is no funeral and no casserole on the porch, people experiencing ambiguous loss often get hit with a second wave of guilt for grieving someone who is still alive — until they realize that gratitude for who is still here and grief for what has changed can both be true in the same heart.

In John 11:33–35, Jesus stood outside the tomb of Lazarus knowing with 100 percent certainty that He was less than two minutes away from raising Lazarus from the dead — and yet "Jesus wept." Knowing the joyful eternal ending did not cancel the present tears; as Ecclesiastes 3:4 teaches, there is both a time to weep and a time to laugh.

And when grief turns into raw anguish or frustration with heaven, history and scripture show that God never asks for fake politeness. In November 1873, Chicago lawyer Horatio Spafford lost all four of his young daughters — Annie, Maggie, Bessie, and Tanetta — when the steamship Ville du Havre sank in twelve minutes in the Atlantic; his surviving wife Anna sent the famous telegram from Wales beginning with the two words, "Saved alone."

Across thirty chapters of the Book of Job, Job refused to hide his anguish behind the tidy religious clichés of his three friends ("I will speak in the anguish of my spirit," Job 7:11; "Though he slay me, yet will I trust in him: but I will maintain mine own ways before him," Job 13:15). At the end of the book, God rebuked the polite friends and commended Job (Job 42:7) — because Job brought his raw, unfiltered pain straight into the room with God, just as the Prophet Joseph Smith cried out "O God, where art thou?" from the freezing stone floor of Liberty Jail and received the Lord’s tender reply: "My son, peace be unto thy soul" (D&C 121:1–7).

Sources

  • John 11:21–35; Ecclesiastes 3:4; 2 Nephi 1:15; Job 7:11; 13:15; 42:7; D&C 121:1–7; Alma 7:11–12 (scripture)
  • Pauline Boss — Ambiguous Loss: Learning to Live with Unresolved Grief, Harvard University Press, 1999 (ideas, attributed)
  • Horatio G. Spafford & Anna Spafford — sinking of the SS Ville du Havre, November 22, 1873 (historical record)
  • Jared Halverson — lectures on Job, Liberty Jail & divine empathy (ideas, attributed)

From the Book: Two Are True

You’re reading the web-only research vault for Two Are True — the deeper clinical, scriptural, and historical receipts behind each chapter.

Book coming soon