Two Are True

The director's cut · web only

Why does God allow suffering?

The long version — the one the one-page chapter didn’t have room for.

There is a question underneath almost every other question people bring to God, and it is not really "why is there evil in the world." It is smaller and far more personal than that. It is: where were You when it was happening to me? The abstract problem of pain is a philosophy seminar. The real wound is a Tuesday afternoon, a phone call, a diagnosis, an empty side of the bed — and the silence that felt like absence.

The first thing worth saying is that the scriptures never once shame the question. Job asks it for thirty-eight chapters. The Psalmist asks it: "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?" And then — this is the part we rush past — Christ Himself prays those exact words from the cross (Matthew 27:46). The most faithful being who ever lived used the language of feeling abandoned by God. If the question were faithless, He would not have asked it.

So the book’s one-page chapter holds two sentences against each other, both spoken by Jesus in the same upper room, hours before Gethsemane: "Peace I leave with you, my peace I give unto you" (John 14:27), and "In the world ye shall have tribulation: but be of good cheer; I have overcome the world" (John 16:33). He did not promise the peace instead of the tribulation. He promised peace inside it. The storm was always part of the forecast.

C.S. Lewis is useful here, and honest in a way that helps. In his calmer book he argued that pain can be the thing that finally gets our attention — that a God who loves us enough to want us whole will not always leave us comfortable. But then his wife died, and he wrote a second, rawer book in which he admitted that all the tidy arguments felt like cold comfort at three in the morning. Both books are true. The theology and the grief are not enemies; they are the two sentences from the upper room, lived out by a real man.

The Latter-day Saint writers Terryl and Fiona Givens add a turn that changes the whole emotional shape of the question. They describe a God who is not aloof from our suffering but moved by it — a God who weeps. The scriptures actually show this: in Moses’ vision, God looks at the suffering of His children and cries (Moses 7:28–37). That is not a God who is absent from your pain. That is a God who is intimate enough to feel it and infinite enough to do something about it — even when the "something" is slower than we would write it.

Viktor Frankl, who built a whole psychology out of a Nazi concentration camp, observed that the people who survived were not the strongest or the most optimistic. They were the ones who could still find a meaning to carry — a person to return to, a work to finish, a why. Suffering with a why is bearable in a way that suffering without one is not. Faith does not erase the pain; it gives the pain somewhere to point.

And then there is Alma’s claim, which is the most specific answer the Restoration gives: that Christ took upon Himself not only our sins but our pains, our sicknesses, our infirmities — "that he may know according to the flesh how to succor his people" (Alma 7:11–12). The point is not that He watched suffering from a safe distance and felt sorry for us. The point is that He went inside it, on purpose, so that there is no part of your worst day He cannot meet you in from the inside.

None of this is meant to make the suffering make sense on a Tuesday afternoon. It is meant to do something the explanations can’t: keep you company. The honest version of this chapter does not hand you a reason. It hands you a Person — one who asked your question first, in your words, and then walked through the thing you are afraid of, ahead of you, so He could be in the boat when the storm finds you.

Sources

  • John 14:27; 16:33; Matthew 27:46; Moses 7:28–37; Alma 7:11–12 (scripture)
  • C.S. Lewis — The Problem of Pain / A Grief Observed (ideas, attributed)
  • Terryl & Fiona Givens — The God Who Weeps (ideas, attributed)
  • Viktor Frankl — Man’s Search for Meaning (ideas, attributed)

From the Book: Two Are True

You’re reading the web-only research vault for Two Are True — the deeper clinical, scriptural, and historical receipts behind each chapter.

Book coming soon