The director's cut · web only
The Football Coach’s Letter: 90 Players, 11 Spots, and What We Say at the Dinner Table
A web-only companion to Chapters 16 & 17 — how a high school football coach’s morning-after letter to parents captures the tension between ambition and brotherhood, sustaining imperfect leaders, and pairing unconditional love with clear guardrails.
After a hard-fought Friday-night win, a high school football coach sent a morning-after note to the parents in his program. He wasn’t trying to write a theology textbook — he was just telling the truth about what it takes to keep ninety teenage boys, their parents, and a coaching staff pulling in the same direction. Yet almost every paragraph of his letter is a living picture of Two Are True in action.
1. Ambition AND Brotherhood (90 Players, 11 Spots): He started with the brutal math of high school football. Ninety boys show up in the weight room right after Thanksgiving, wake up early all summer, and miss family vacations to earn a spot — and on Friday night, only eleven players can be on the field at a time, leaving the vast majority standing on the sideline, never hearing their name called. Even the coaches’ own sons were not exempt: one coach’s son barely played a dozen snaps in high school because another player was ahead of him at that position (and that same boy kept working, grew into his frame, and went on to start at left tackle for a Division I college program). Another coach’s son played very little on Friday nights, yet chose to be the glue of the locker room. When a teammate blocked a kick late in the game, 100 percent of all ninety players erupted on the sideline in brotherly love. They wanted to play with all their hearts — and they rejoiced when their brother made the play. Both were true.
2. Imperfect Leaders AND Dinner-Table Loyalty: Next, the coach named the quiet trap that ruins both sports teams and church experience. When our child isn’t getting the ball or a decision doesn’t go our way, our brains start inventing stories that feel 100 percent true: "The coach doesn’t like me. We don’t have the right last name. We aren’t in the right circle." And then we go home and roast the leader at the dinner table: "Your coach is dumb — why does Johnny play?" Look at how disarmingly the coach answered that: "I will be the first to tell you I have made more mistakes than I can begin to count. Sometimes you’re right — coaches are sometimes not smart. We make mistakes in every aspect of the game every week. However, that’s not the point. Stay positive with your son. Those lessons will take them much further in life than anything that happens on the field." Sustaining a bishop, a youth leader, a teacher, or a coach never meant pretending they are infallible. It means refusing to poison the dinner table while your kids are learning how to finish something hard together.
3. Unconditional Love AND "Trust, But Always Verify": Finally, the coach held both sides of the parenting coin together in two paragraphs that most modern advice tears apart. On one side, he pleaded with parents to give 100 percent unconditional love: "Be their biggest fan. Playing time or not, let them know how proud you are. Your love doesn’t come from whether or not they score or get in a game. It’s unconditional and always will be unconditional." And right beside that unconditional love, he urged parents to keep clear-eyed guardrails: teenagers are navigating fierce pressure around friends, dating, and fitting in, so check the phone, ask the hard questions, trust your gut, and tell your son up front that he is under your watch because you love him too much to look the other way. As Jesus taught in Matthew 10:16, you can be wise as a serpent with your boundaries and harmless as a dove with your love at the exact same time.
Sources
- 1 Corinthians 12:14–26; D&C 107:27–29; Matthew 10:16 (scripture)
- James E. Faust — "Keeping Covenants and Honoring the Priesthood," October 1993 General Conference (ideas, attributed)
- High school football coach’s letter to parents (shared with permission, names anonymized)
From the Book: Two Are True
You’re reading the web-only research vault for Two Are True — the deeper clinical, scriptural, and historical receipts behind each chapter.