Two Are True

The director's cut · web only

Captain Your Story, Unchained & Why Boundaries Make Second Chances Possible

A web-only companion to Chapter 10 — how Utah’s My Story Matters (Captain Your Story), the prisoner-made film Unchained, and criminologist Shadd Maruna’s research show what happens when real accountability meets a community willing to believe in your future.

Prison does not end at the prison gate. Every week, men and women finish serving their sentences, pay their legal debt to society, and walk out genuinely determined to build an honest life — only to hit an invisible wall where almost nobody wants to hire them, rent an apartment to them, or sit beside them at church. In his landmark Liverpool Desistance Study (Making Good: How Ex-Convicts Reform and Rebuild Their Lives, American Psychological Association, 2001), criminologist Dr. Shadd Maruna interviewed hundreds of former prisoners to understand why so many relapse while others turn their lives around for good. He found that no human being can rebuild a broken identity in total isolation: when everyone on the outside hands a returning person a "Condemnation Script" — insisting that they are forever defined by their worst mistake, and judging anyone who treats them kindly — despair takes over and people almost always reoffend.

For lasting change to take root, Maruna found, a person needs a "Redemption Script": honest ownership of what they did wrong paired with at least one person or community brave enough to treat them like their future is larger than their past — just as Barnabas took a repentant Saul of Tarsus by the arm when everyone in Jerusalem was understandably afraid of him (Acts 9:26–27), and just as Bishop Myriel set two silver candlesticks on the table in front of Jean Valjean in Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables.

You can watch both sides of that coin working in real life right now inside Utah’s prisons through My Story Matters (mystorymatters.org), a Springville, Utah nonprofit founded by Amy Chandler, and its twelve-week curriculum Captain Your Story. Taught inside the Utah State Correctional Facility in Salt Lake City, the Central Utah Correctional Facility in Gunnison, and county jails — often alongside an inmate’s own family taking the exact same course on the outside — Captain Your Story never excuses the past or softens accountability. Instead, participants spend weeks practicing radical honesty about the choices that brought them there, learning emotional regulation and healthy boundaries, and building a concrete plan for who they will be when they walk out.

Demand inside the walls has grown to a 700-person waitlist, and My Story Matters took the groundbreaking step of training and certifying more than thirty incarcerated men and women as peer Guides so inmates themselves now mentor and teach fellow residents behind bars. Whereas roughly four out of five released prisoners typically reoffend without support, My Story Matters reports that 99 percent of its justice-involved graduates remain free of reincarceration. When skeptics ask Amy Chandler whether inmates simply "belong there," she answers with both halves of the gospel coin at once: she explains that she is never there to rob justice, because justice must be paid — she is there to help men and women become their best selves so that when they return to our neighborhoods, we can welcome them safely and cheer for their success.

That same transformation comes to life on screen in Unchained, a film created by prisoners themselves inside prison walls. Watching incarcerated men and women step behind and in front of the camera to tell the unfiltered truth about what broke in their lives, the hard work of owning the wreckage, and what wakes up inside a human soul the moment someone treats them as a son or daughter of God instead of a prison number makes Jesus’s dinner at Zacchaeus’s house feel immediate (Luke 19:1–10). Shame locks people inside their worst chapter; dignified accountability plus real hope hands them the pen to write the next one.

At the same time, keeping a chair open at the table never means becoming a boundaryless doormat or putting your family in harm’s way. When researcher Dr. Brené Brown (Rising Strong, 2015) interviewed the most genuinely compassionate, forgiving people she could find, she discovered that they also kept the clearest boundaries of anyone in her research — because knowing your firm guardrails on time, place, and setting is the very thing that keeps you safe enough to love people without carrying a stone in your hand. Just like Joseph in Egypt carefully testing whether his brothers were safe before bringing them into the palace (Genesis 42–45), being "wise as serpents, and harmless as doves" (Matthew 10:16) lets us protect what is entrusted to us while cheering whole-heartedly for everyone fighting to come home.

Sources

From the Book: Two Are True

You’re reading the web-only research vault for Two Are True — the deeper clinical, scriptural, and historical receipts behind each chapter.

Book coming soon