TopicsForgiveness
Book coming soon

Christ already paid the bill. You don't have to collect it.

A woman setting down a heavy stone on the ground beside her, looking forward, not back.

Shame's Lie versus God's Thoughts

Shame's Lie

If forgiveness were real, the hurt would be gone. It isn't — so I must be bitter, not faithful.

God's Thoughts

Forgiving them does not mean pretending it didn't happen. Christ released her — and named the sin — in the same breath.

Watch these

The Ministry of Reconciliation

Elder Jeffrey R. Holland

Holland insists that the gospel asks for real forgiveness — but he makes equally clear that reconciliation in cases of abuse, ongoing harm, or unrepented serious sin requires wisdom, sometimes professional help, and sometimes a long time. "There must be no abuse of any kind in our homes." He extends the gospel of reconciliation to the wounded without requiring them to walk back into the wound.

Proving Polarities

Jared Halverson (Faith Matters podcast, ep. 125)

The frame this entire page is built on. Halverson takes Joseph Smith's "by proving contraries, truth is made manifest" and applies it to the doctrines that look like contradictions and aren't. Mercy and justice is the central example. He returns again and again to John 8:11 — "Neither do I condemn thee… go, and sin no more" — as proof that the Lord holds both poles at full strength, in the same breath, with no mushy middle.

The contrary

Both halves came from the same Lord, in the same breath. This is what Joseph Smith meant by proving contraries — and what Halverson means by a polarity. Mercy and justice met at the cross. Neither one waters down the other.

"Neither do I condemn thee…"

— John 8:11

"…go, and sin no more."

— John 8:11

Prophet voices

"Mercy cannot rob justice. … Both laws stood fulfilled. Because there was a mediator, justice had claimed its full share, and mercy was fully satisfied."

— President Boyd K. PackerThe Mediator, April 1977 General Conference

"[Christ] still extends unending grace, although He extends it with pierced palms and scarred wrists."

— Elder D. Todd ChristoffersonWhere Justice, Love, and Mercy Meet, April 2015 General Conference (Easter Sunday)

"There must be no abuse of any kind in our homes — verbal abuse, emotional abuse, certainly not physical abuse. Husbands, love your wives. Wives, love your husbands. And both of you, love your children."

— Elder Jeffrey R. HollandThe Ministry of Reconciliation, October 2018 General Conference

More than one side of the same God

Christ on the cross — mercy released, and justice was paid.

"Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do" (Luke 23:34). The most quoted line on forgiveness in scripture was spoken by a man being murdered by the very people He was forgiving. He released them to the Father — but the forgiveness was not free, and Christ did not pretend the harm wasn't real. He paid for it. "I, God, have suffered these things for all, that they might not suffer if they would repent; but if they would not repent they must suffer even as I; which suffering caused myself, even God, the greatest of all, to tremble because of pain, and to bleed at every pore, and to suffer both body and spirit" (D&C 19:16–18). The bill came due. The bill got paid. The mercy is real because the justice is real — not in spite of it.

Luke 23:34; D&C 19:16–18

Read more from the bookFull scenario, scripture, and the both-are-good frame

Both are good

Mercy that releases.

Luke 23:34

Justice that names the wrong.

Alma 42:25

Read the moment

A woman, forty-five, sits in her car in the church parking lot before sacrament meeting. Her father — who was cruel to her in ways the family pretends did not happen — is dying in another state. People keep telling her you have to forgive him before he goes. The Sunday School lesson three weeks ago was on D&C 64:10. She has read every "forgiveness" article in the Liahona archive. She still cannot make herself call him. What no one in her life has separated for her — and what scripture clearly does — is that forgiveness is not the erasure of what happened. Forgiveness is what she does in her own heart, in front of God: I release this man to You. I will not poison the rest of my life carrying him. The bill is paid. I do not need to collect. That is the mercy side, and it is required of every disciple. But the gospel never asked her to pretend the harm wasn't real. "Mercy can rob justice? Nay; not one whit" (Alma 42:25). What he did was real. What he did was wrong. God Himself refuses to pretend otherwise. Christ Himself paid for it — in His own body, in His own blood. That is the justice side, and the woman in the parking lot does not have to carry it. Christ is not asking her to ratify "it didn't really happen" in order to forgive. He is asking her to let the One who already paid be the One who collects. She can do the first today, alone, in the car. She can release him to a God who knows everything about both of them. She does not, in order to be obedient, have to drive to his bedside. God is not asking her to be unsafe in order to be saved.

"What, do ye suppose that mercy can rob justice? I say unto you, Nay; not one whit. If so, God would cease to be God."

— Alma 42:25

God's Example

Where justice, love, and mercy meet.

On the cross, mercy and justice did not compromise. Both stood at full strength. Christ said "Father, forgive them" (Luke 23:34) — full mercy — while every farthing of justice was paid in His own body, His own blood, His own trembling at every pore (D&C 19:16–18). The Atonement is not mercy waiving justice. It is mercy and justice meeting in one act. Eliza R. Snow named it in the hymn that both President Packer and Elder Christofferson chose to close their landmark talks on this contrary: "How great, how glorious, how complete, / Redemption's grand design, / Where justice, love, and mercy meet / In harmony divine!"

Luke 23:34; D&C 19:16–18; Hymn 195

Bridle it: right time, right place, right person, right reason.

God doesn't approve of either extreme

This is not an excuse. God wants both — mercy that releases the offender to Him and justice that says what they did was real. Bridle this.

Becoming the avenger God reserved for Himself

When "I haven't forgiven them" becomes the lens through which you describe yourself for years — when the wound becomes the identity, the bitterness becomes the personality, every conversation circles back to what they did, and you are quietly trying to be the avenger God reserved for Himself — the offender now controls two lives instead of one. Vengeance is mine, saith the Lord (Rom 12:19). The release is for your sake. Carrying the verdict forever does not punish them. It only continues their work. The justice you keep trying to collect is justice that was paid for two thousand years ago. Let the Collector collect.

"Dearly beloved, avenge not yourselves… Vengeance is mine; I will repay, saith the Lord."

— Romans 12:19

False mercy that pretends the harm wasn't real

Try to "forgive" by pretending the harm wasn't real, never naming it, never feeling it, and reentering relationships before any change has happened? You will retraumatize yourself, your children, and the people watching you. That is not what God asked of you. That is mercy robbing justice — and Alma 42:25 says God Himself will not do that, not one whit. Holland is plain on this. The Church's own Gospel Topic on abuse is plain on this. Forgiveness is real. Pretending is not the same thing. False mercy is not Christlike. It is a lie wearing Christ's name.

"What, do ye suppose that mercy can rob justice? I say unto you, Nay; not one whit. If so, God would cease to be God."

— Alma 42:25

Take the bread. Take the water. Adjust. Come back.

Hand this to someone.

Two Are True is a small, gift-able book — designed to be opened to any page and read in under a minute. Send a copy. Leave one in a bathroom. Give one to a teenager.

Get the book — coming soon